| Aretha Franklin | First Snow In Kokomo | The Atlantic Albums Collection* |
| Ryan Adams | Hotel Chelsea Nights | Love Is Hell |
| Joni Mitchell | Chelsea Morning | Clouds |
| Lena Horne | Take It Slow, Joe (Ho Ho Ho) | The Essential |
| Songs of Green Pheasant | I Am Daylights | Songs of Green Pheasant |
| Khruangbin | A Calf Born in Winter (single) | |
| The Byrds | Draft Morning | The Notorious Byrd Brothers |
| Fleetwood Mac | Albatross | The Pious Bird of Good Omen |
| Sin Fang Bous | A Fire to Sleep In | Clangour |
| Steve Ashley | Fire and Wine | Stroll On |
| set 2 | | |
| Daniel Taylor & The Trinity Choir | Hodie Christus natus est | Four Thousand Winter* |
| Lorne Greene | Merry Christmas All You Shining Stars (Wonderful Sound) | |
| Abigail Washburn | Bright Morning Stars | City of Refuge |
| Mark Lanegan | You Only Live Twice | Imitations |
| Peggy Lee | A Little White Ship | Mirrors |
| Matthew E. White | Hot Toddies | Big Inner |
| set 3 | | |
| David Bowie | Come and Buy My Toys | David Bowie |
| Nadia Sirota | Lo, How a Rose E'er Blooming | |
| The White Stripes | Candy Cane Children (Single) | |
| Cream | Deserted Cities of the Heart | Wheels of Fire |
| Caleb Burhans | o come, o come emmanuel | |
| Here We Go Magic | Falling | Be Small* |
| Doug Balliet | Xmas Crab | |
| set 4 | | |
| Wynton Marsalis & Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra | Jingle Bells | Big Band Holidays* |
| Riders In the Sky | Let It Snow/The Last Christmas Medley You'll Ever Need to Hear | Christmas the Cowboy Way |
| set 5 | | |
| The Albion Christmas Band | Burn, Logs, Burn | A Sound in the Frosty Air |
| Laura Marling | Goodbye England (Covered In Snow) | I Speak Because I Can |
| Nadia Sirota | Medieval Xmas | |
| Jane Child | World Lullabye | Jane Child |
| Mixo aka Applause Beetz | Ebenezer Scrooge | The Future in the Present |
| Brian Auger & Julie Tippets | Spirit | Encore |
| The Divine Comedy | Charmed Life | Absent Friends |
| set 6 | | |
| Nadia Sirota/Alexander Overington | Knee Christmas | |
| Syd Arthur | Edge of the Earth | On an On |
| Nico Muhly | Jesus Christ that Apple Tree | |
| Laura Nyro | Christmas In My Soul | Christmas And The Beads of Sweat |
| Hannis Brown | Antfarm Grandfather Clock | |
| Elton John | Come Down In Time | Tumbleweed Connection |
| Aaron Roche | angels etc. | |
| Phoebe Snow | Drink Up The Melody (Bite The Dust Blues) | It Looks Like Snow |
| set 7 | | |
| Phil Ochs | Canons of Christianity | Phil Ochs In Concert |
| Nick Lowe | Failed Christian | Dig My Mood |
| The Byrds | The Christian Life | Sweetheart Of The Radio |
| set 8 | | |
| Loudon Wainwright III | Suddenly It's Christmas | Career Moves |
| David Wilcox | Jesus Ruins Christmas | |
| The Wood Brothers | Rebel Jesus | My Favorite Gifts |
| Evangelist | God Song | Evangelist* |
| Deep Dish, Richard Morel & Brian Transeau | Mohammad is Jesus... | Junk Science |
| Susan Werner | (Why Is Your) Heaven So Small | The Gospel Truth |
| Mollie O'Brien & Rich Moore | Saints & Sinners | Saints & Sinners |
| Suzzy & Maggie Roche | Couldn't Hear Nobody Pray | Zero Church |
| Simon & Garfunkel | Bleecker Street (Demo) | Old Friends |
| Paul Simon | Questions For The Angels | So Beautiful Or So What |
| set 9 | | |
| Rev. J.M. Gates | Where Will You be On Christmas Day? | Rev. J.M. Gates Vol. 5 (1927) |
| Anders Osborne | Had My Reasons | Living Room |
| Glass Vaults | Ancient Gates | |
| John McCutcheon | Christmas In The Trenches | |
| Along The Road | A Christmas Truce | The Days Draw Close To Christmas |
| Ry Cooder | Christmas Time This Year | Pull Up Some Dust And Sit Down |
| Billy Bragg | Northern Industrial Town | William Bloke |
| Ladysmith Black Mambazo | Prince of Peace | llembe: Honoring Shaka Zulu |
| set 10 | | |
| Bob Dylan | Twas The Night Before Christmas (from Theme Time Radio Hour) | |
| Bob Dylan | Must Be Santa | Christmas In The Heart |
| set 11 | | |
| Sharon Jones & The Dap Kings | Big Bulbs | It's a Holiday Soul Party* |
| Nina Simone | Chilly Winds Don't Blow | Pastel Blues |
| Amos Milburn | Let's Make Christmas Merry Baby | Blues, Blues Christmas |
| Michael Weiskopf | Here's To Love | Love & Entropy* |
| Little Isidore & The Inquisitors | Christmas of Love | How the Grinch Stole Christmas |
| Herb Alpert | Love Affair | Come Fly With Me* |
| Drew Holcomb & The Neighbors | Everything's Changed at Christmas | |
| set 12 | | |
| Phil Kline/Nadia Sirota | In Christmas | |
| Mike Doughty | I Hear the Bells | Haughty Music |
| Nadia Sirota/Alexander Overington | Christmas Phase | |
| Joan As Police Woman | Holiday | To Survive |
| Alexander Overington | Behold | |
| Ray Charles | Sinner's Prayer | Pure Genius: The Complete Atlantic Recordings (1952 - 1959) |
| Brad Balliet | Cantique de Noel | |
| Caetano Veloso | In the Hot Sun of Christmas Day | Caetano Veloso |
| set 13 | | |
| Khruangbin | Mr. White | The Universe Smiles Upon You* |
| Beta Radio | Winter Eclipse | The Songs the Season Brings* |
