s/s Montauk Hwy, @ Athasca Rd

631-581-9888

This friendly old tavern, which features a simple bar, roaring jukebox and nice pub grub, caters to longstanding customers who are mainly over 40.

Darts enthusiasts and top-tier throwers also hang out at this spot. The appeal lies in six boards lining the back walls. Don't worry if you're new to the sport; all are invited to jump in and give it a go in between sanctioned league games. In business for 106 years, the bar's current owners have been there 25 years.